We use cookies to improve your experience on our platform. By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage and assist in our marketing efforts.
Cookies required for basic website functionality.
Cookies used to deliver content most relevant to you and your needs.
Cookies used to deliver content most relevant to you and your needs.
Cookies that help understand the performance of the website, how users interact with it and to identify bugs.
How is Zeffy free?
How is Zeffy free?
Zeffy relies entirely on optional contributions from donors. At the payment confirmation step - we ask donors to leave an optional contribution to Zeffy.
Hiring the right team can make or break your nonprofit's impact. As funding gets tighter and donor expectations rise, having a passionate, skilled team aligned with your mission becomes crucial.
Beyond standard qualifications, nonprofit roles require unique combinations of program expertise, resource management skills, and genuine commitment to social change.
Let’s explore 44 strategic interview questions to help you identify candidates who will drive your mission forward in 2025. From assessing cultural fit to evaluating crisis management abilities, these questions are designed to reveal competence and the dedication and adaptability your nonprofit needs to thrive.
Why is it important for nonprofits to ask tailored questions in interviews?
Nonprofit roles demand a unique blend of professional skills and mission-driven motivation. Unlike corporate interviews focused primarily on technical abilities, nonprofit interviews must assess a candidate's commitment to social impact and ability to thrive with limited resources.
A development director, for instance, needs more than fundraising experience - they must genuinely connect with donors while managing tight budgets and program constraints. Similarly, program managers require both operational expertise and deep empathy for the communities they serve.
By crafting targeted questions, you can evaluate both professional capabilities and mission alignment. This helps identify candidates who will advance your cause while building meaningful relationships with stakeholders and tackling nonprofit-specific challenges.
4 types of interview questions nonprofits must ask
1. Introduction questions
Start with questions that help candidates feel comfortable while giving you insights into their professional journey. Ask open-ended questions like:
What drew you to the nonprofit sector?
Tell me about your experience working with mission-driven organizations.
What aspects of nonprofit work do you find most rewarding?
These questions encourage natural conversation and reveal genuine interests without immediately testing mission alignment. Save mission-specific questions for later in the interview when candidates are more relaxed and can provide authentic responses.
2. Nonprofit knowledge and experience-based questions
Focus on understanding their familiarity with nonprofit work and past contributions. For instance, ask, “How have you supported a similar mission in the past?” or “What do you know about our nonprofit’s goals?” to measure their expertise, willingness to learn, and level of interest.
3. Skill-based questions aligned with organizational needs
Nonprofits often face unique challenges like limited budgets, and coordinating between donors, volunteers, board members, and community partners, while maintaining efficient volunteer-based operations.
Candidates with specific skills like fundraising, volunteer coordination, grant writing, and community outreach can add tremendous value to your nonprofit.
4. Cultural fit and mission alignment questions
Assess how well they connect with your organization’s values. For example, “What does our mission mean to you personally?” or “How do you work with diverse teams to further a shared cause?” helps you understand their adaptability and dedication.
21 general nonprofit interview questions
General questions help you clearly understand a candidate’s background and qualifications. Unlike specific questions, these are broader and show if the person is a good overall match for your nonprofit before diving into role-specific details.
Values, goals, and mission
To see whether a candidate is truly interested in your mission, check their research about your organization. It helps you understand their keenness and problem-solving approach. Here are some questions you can ask:
What do you know about our mission and the work we do?
What values do you think are most important for someone working here?
If you could suggest one new goal for us, what would it be and why?
Here’s a problem [mention a specific issue] we’ve faced before. What would you do to make it better?
How would you help us grow while staying true to what we stand for?
Experience
Assessing a candidate’s past accomplishments and ability to overcome challenges is essential for challenging roles that require adaptability and on-the-feet thinking. Ask questions that encourage them to reflect on their experience, such as:
What’s one challenge you faced in nonprofit work, and how did you resolve it?
Describe a professional failure and what you learned from it.
Describe a fundraising campaign you contributed to. What was your role, and what was the outcome?
What’s a program or initiative you helped develop or improve? What steps did you take, and what were the results?
What’s a time when you identified a gap in your nonprofit’s strategy and helped fill it?
How have you navigated disagreements within a team while working on a nonprofit project?
Describe a time when you built strong relationships with donors, partners, or sponsors. How did it benefit the nonprofit?
These scenarios provide insight into their critical thinking skills and ability to grow from past experiences.
Sample questions to ensure readiness
Here’s a list of must-ask questions to see whether your candidates can fulfill your nonprofit's demands:
Can you describe a time when you had to juggle multiple responsibilities and how you managed them?
What would you do if a key donor or volunteer suddenly withdrew their support for a project?
How would you approach building relationships with community stakeholders who may not initially support your nonprofit’s mission?
How would you handle a situation where a program’s funding was unexpectedly cut?
Can you share an example of how you’ve successfully motivated a team during a challenging project?
How would you manage conflicts between volunteers or team members with differing viewpoints?
How do you ensure inclusivity and representation in your nonprofit’s programs or events?
Can you describe how you’ve handled an ethical dilemma in a nonprofit setting?
How would you prioritize competing needs across multiple programs or initiatives?
By asking these general questions, you can establish whether the candidate has the values, experience, and mindset to succeed in your nonprofit’s environment.
Soft skills and leadership
Leading nonprofits requires unique abilities to inspire teams while managing complex stakeholder relationships. These questions assess adaptability and emotional intelligence:
Describe a crisis you managed in a nonprofit setting. How did you maintain team morale while solving the problem?
How do you adjust your leadership style when working with different stakeholders?
Remote and hybrid work
Modern nonprofits often operate in mixed environments. These questions assess virtual leadership:
How do you maintain donor and volunteer engagement in a virtual environment?
What strategies do you use to build team culture in hybrid settings?
Ethical decision-making
Nonprofits frequently face complex moral choices. This question examines judgment:
Tell me about a time you faced an ethical dilemma involving donor expectations versus program needs.
Fundraising and grant writing
Sustainable funding requires relationship building and compelling communication:
How do you maintain donor relationships during economic downturns?
Describe your approach to crafting grant narratives that stand out.
Diversity and Inclusion
Modern nonprofits must serve diverse communities effectively:
How have you promoted inclusive practices in previous roles?
What strategies would you use to ensure our programs serve diverse communities effectively?
14 role-specific interview questions for nonprofits
Executive directors
Executive directors lead a nonprofit organization, oversee programs, manage teams, and secure funding. Ask questions that test their leadership, strategic thinking, and problem-solving abilities, such as:
What is your experience with managing teams in a nonprofit organization, and how have you motivated employees or volunteers to meet organizational goals?
Can you describe a time when you led a nonprofit through a major challenge and what strategies you used to overcome it?
How do you develop and implement strategies to engage donors and raise funds to support the organization’s mission?
Volunteers interact directly with your target communities, serving as the face of your cause, so gauging their motivation and skills is important. Relevant questions include:
Why are you interested in joining our nonprofit as a volunteer, and what do you hope to achieve through this role?
Have you worked on nonprofit projects before, and how did you contribute to their success?
6 tips for conducting effective nonprofit interviews
Research the candidate’s background: Review their resume and past nonprofit work to assess how their skills match your organization’s goals
Be flexible with interview venues and timings: Offering options for in-person or virtual interviews and accommodating schedules shows that you value the candidate’s time and commitment
Send preparation materials: Share links to your nonprofit’s website, ongoing initiatives, or social media. Later ask thoughtful questions like, “What did you notice about our campaigns, and how would you improve them?”
Use a consistent structure: Stick to a clear format, like behavioral questions, to compare candidates fairly
Encourage candidate questions: Allow them to ask about the nonprofit’s mission, programs, and goals to gauge their interest
Close with clarity: Explain the next steps and provide a timeline for decisions to keep the process transparent
Final thoughts on nonprofit interview questions
Finding the right person for your nonprofit is about building a team that can make a real impact. Thoughtful interviews help you go beyond resumes to identify candidates who align with your mission and values.
By focusing on specific skills, passion, and cultural fit, you can hire people who will contribute to lasting change in your community. Supplement custom questions with general inquiries about the candidate to drive your organization’s goals forward effectively.
Small nonprofits can create comprehensive interview processes even without dedicated HR staff. The key is creating structure while keeping implementation simple.
Start with these foundational elements:
Form an interview committee of 2-3 team members and a board member
Assign clear focus areas like skills, culture, and leadership potential
Create a simple 1-5 scoring system for consistent evaluation
Document feedback using basic templates or free online tools
Research similar roles at other nonprofits and adapt their questions for your context. Include practical exercises that reflect real job responsibilities - for example, have development candidates pitch a mock donor program or ask program managers to solve actual challenges you've faced.
Creating truly inclusive interviews requires a comprehensive approach that addresses both accessibility and evaluation methods.
Start by removing logistical barriers - offer flexible scheduling options and multiple interview formats (video, phone, in-person)
Share clear details about the interview process, location accessibility, and any advance preparation needed
During the interview, use clear, jargon-free language and avoid making assumptions about candidates' backgrounds or experiences
Train your interview panel on recognizing unconscious bias and ensure diverse representation among interviewers when possible
Give candidates sufficient time to respond and offer breaks during longer sessions
Develop consistent evaluation criteria focused on core competencies rather than traditional experience metrics alone
Remember that inclusive hiring isn't just about accommodations - it's about creating an environment where all candidates can authentically demonstrate their potential to contribute to your mission.
Interviews are a big part of finding the right person for your nonprofit, but it's easy to make mistakes along the way. Here are some common ones you can avoid:
Not asking questions that are specific to the role and its responsibilities
Relying too much on what's written on the resume instead of digging deeper into their experience
Forgetting to explain your nonprofit's mission, goals, and what you stand for
Skipping practical questions about how they'd handle real challenges in your organization
Rushing through the interview without asking follow-up questions
Leaving out key team members or stakeholders who could provide helpful input
Overlooking volunteer work or unpaid experience that could be very relevant
Not asking about their motivation or passion for working with your nonprofit
Giving a vague job description that doesn't clearly explain the role or expectations
Only focusing on what they can do right now and not thinking about their potential to grow
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Keep reading :
Nonprofit guides
Guide to Marketing Jobs in the Nonprofit Sector
Nonprofits thrive with strong marketing strategies. Learn about the best marketing jobs for nonprofits with our guide - skills, salary, and job description.
Executive Director Job Description 2024: 5 Key Responsibilities to Know About
Discover the responsibilities of an executive director in a nonprofit. Read on to find the three vital skills to develop to be the best executive director.
Role of a Nonprofit CEO: Responsibilities and Salary (+ Sample Job Description)
Explore the role of a nonprofit CEO, including their key skills, responsibilities, and salary. Learn what it takes to lead a nonprofit organization to success.
