PayPal VS Square

PayPal and Square help you accept donations, but they charge processing fees that reduce what reaches your mission. Zeffy gives you donation forms, event ticketing, peer-to-peer fundraising, and donor management — all with zero fees so you keep 100% of every donation.

Decorative

Zeffy is trusted by 100,000+ nonprofits

Sign up to Zeffy for free - 100% free forever.
Square
logo-dark-PayPal
Decorative

PayPal VS Square

PayPal VS Square: What nonprofits should know before choosing.

PayPal
Square
Payment processing Features
PayPal:
Square:
Payments processing
PayPal:
Yes

Square:
Yes

0% Processing / Transaction Fee
PayPal:
No

Square:
No

ACH / Bank Transfers
PayPal:
Yes

Square:
Yes

Credit / Debit Card Acceptance
PayPal:
Yes

Square:
Yes

Digital Wallets (Apple Pay, Google Pay)
PayPal:
Yes

Square:
Yes

International Payments
PayPal:
Yes

Square:
Yes

Fraud Detection
PayPal:
Yes

Square:
Yes

Built in Fundraising Tools (Tickets, Auctions, Forms. etc.)
PayPal:
No

Square:
No

PCI Compliance
PayPal:
Yes

Square:
Yes

Pricing
PayPal:

N/A.

No pricing information available

Square:

$23/mo + 3%.

card fees

Processing fees
PayPal:

1.99% + $0.49.

Charity transactions: fixed fee per transaction (for confirmed/eligible charities). International transactions add 1.50%. For other charity services and non-confirmed charity rates see full breakdown

Square:

N/A.

No pricing information available

Platform fees
PayPal:

$0.

No fee

Square:

3%.

on Business plan for donations; 0% on Commerce plans

Monthly fees
PayPal:

$5.00/month.

Most services have no monthly fee. Optional services include Payments Pro $30.00/month, Payflow Pro $25.00/month, Recurring Billing $10.00/month, and others

Square:

$23/mo.

Business plan (~$276/yr). 10% off for nonprofits first year

Value for money
PayPal:

4.5.

450+ reviews on Capterra; affordable for nonprofits with strong free offering

Square:

N/A.

Features
PayPal:

4.5/5.

Familiar payment processor, but requires multiple tools for nonprofits

Square:

4.3/5.

Retail-focused platform with high fees and limited nonprofit features

Donations
PayPal:
Yes

PayPal accepts donations but charges 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction, eating into your fundraising dollars

Square:
Yes

Square supports one-time donations through payment links and forms, but lacks nonprofit-specific features like donor management or recurring giving tools.

Ticketing
PayPal:
No

No built-in event ticketing system - you'll need separate tools to sell tickets and manage attendees

Square:
No

Square offers basic event payment processing, but lacks event management features like seating charts, check-in tools, or attendee communication.

Peer-to-Peer Fundraising
PayPal:
No

Limited peer-to-peer fundraising support - donors can't easily create their own fundraising pages

Square:
No

Square doesn't offer peer-to-peer fundraising capabilities. You'd need third-party software to create fundraising campaigns for supporters.

Auctions
PayPal:
No

No auction functionality - you'll need additional software to run silent or live auctions

Square:
No

Square doesn't offer auction functionality. You'd need separate auction software and handle payment processing manually through Square's system.

Raffles
PayPal:
No

No raffle management features - requires third-party integrations to run raffles and track entries

Square:
No

Square processes payments but doesn't provide raffle-specific tools like ticket management, winner selection, or compliance tracking features.

Online store
PayPal:
Yes

Basic payment processing for online sales but lacks nonprofit-specific features like tax receipts

Square:
Yes

Square provides e-commerce tools with inventory management, but charges transaction fees and monthly subscription costs for online store features.

Memberships
PayPal:
No

PayPal doesn't offer built-in membership management. You'll need third-party tools to handle recurring memberships and member communications.

Square:
No

Square doesn't offer built-in membership management. You'd need to integrate with third-party membership platforms or manage renewals manually through separate systems.

Donor Management/CRM
PayPal:
No

Basic transaction records only. No donor profiles, giving history tracking, or relationship management features for your supporters.

Square:
No

Square provides basic customer profiles but lacks nonprofit-specific features like donation tracking, donor segmentation, or giving history that nonprofits need.

Emails & Newsletter
PayPal:
No

No email marketing features. You'll need separate tools like Mailchimp or Constant Contact to send newsletters to your supporters.

Square:
No

Square lacks email marketing tools. You'll need to export donor data and use separate platforms like Mailchimp, creating extra steps and potential data sync issues.

Payment Processing
PayPal:
No

Accepts donations online with 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction fees. No special nonprofit rates or fee-free options available.

Square:
No

Accepts donations online with 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction fees. No special nonprofit rates or fee-free options available.

Payment methods
PayPal:
No

Cards and digital wallets only, no bank transfers

Square:
Yes

All payment types but requires hardware purchase

Credit Card Payments
PayPal:
Yes

Supported - Accepts Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover with transaction fees

Square:
Yes

Yes - Square accepts all major credit cards with competitive processing rates

Apple Pay & Google Pay
PayPal:
Yes

Supported - Processes Apple Pay and Google Pay through PayPal checkout

Square:
Yes

Yes - Square supports both Apple Pay and Google Pay for contactless payments

ACH / Bank Transfers
PayPal:
No

Not supported - PayPal focuses on card payments and PayPal transfers, not ACH bank transfers

Square:
Yes

Yes - Square supports ACH bank transfers for online payments

Tap to Pay App
PayPal:
No

Limited - Offers PayPal Zettle for in-person payments but requires separate hardware purchase

Square:
Yes

Yes - Square offers tap-to-pay functionality through their mobile app and card readers

Customer Support
PayPal:

4.5/5.

Square:

4.3/5.

Unlimited Support
PayPal:
Yes

PayPal offers tiered support based on account type and transaction volume

Square:
Yes

Square offers tiered support based on your plan and transaction volume

Phone Support / Office Hours
PayPal:
Yes

PayPal provides phone support during standard business hours for eligible accounts

Square:
Yes

Square provides phone support during standard business hours for merchants

Webinars
PayPal:
Yes

PayPal offers occasional educational webinars for business users

Square:
Yes

Square offers occasional webinars and educational sessions for business owners

Help Center
PayPal:
Yes

PayPal maintains a comprehensive help center with articles and FAQs

Square:
Yes

Square maintains a comprehensive help center with articles and guides

Email
PayPal:
Yes

PayPal provides live chat support during business hours

Square:
Yes

Square provides live chat support during business hours for account holders

Nonprofit-Focused Support Team
PayPal:
No

Support built for businesses, not nonprofits. Access varies by account type and transaction volume.

Square:
No

Support designed for merchants and businesses. Help level depends on your plan and transaction volume.

Zeffy is 100% free, always.

Why Zeffy over PayPal and Square?

Why choose Zeffy over PayPal and Square if you're a nonprofit

🎟️

Keep 100% of your raffle proceeds

PayPal and Square take 3% of every ticket sold. Zeffy charges zero fees, so your 50/50 draw or basket raffle actually raises money for your mission.

🎯

Run complete fundraising campaigns without monthly fees

PayPal lacks auction tools while Square charges $23/month plus fees. Zeffy provides raffles, auctions, and ticketing at no cost to your organization.

🤝

Get dedicated nonprofit support when you need it

PayPal and Square offer basic business hours support. Zeffy provides unlimited nonprofit-focused help because donors have the option to leave a voluntary contribution.

Frequently asked questions

How does Zeffy's pricing compare to PayPal and Square for small nonprofits?

Zeffy is completely free - no transaction fees, monthly costs, or setup charges. PayPal takes 2.9% + $0.30 per donation, while Square charges $23/month plus 3% fees. A nonprofit raising $10,000 saves over $300 annually with Zeffy.

Can Zeffy handle all our fundraising needs unlike payment processors?

Yes, Zeffy includes everything you need: donation forms, event ticketing, auctions, raffles, donor management, and tax receipts. PayPal and Square only process payments - you'd need multiple expensive tools to match what Zeffy offers for free.

Why should nonprofits choose Zeffy over PayPal or Square for donations?

Zeffy is 100% free for nonprofits - no transaction fees, monthly costs, or hidden charges. PayPal takes 2.9% + $0.30 per donation, while Square charges $23/month plus 3% fees. Every dollar donated goes directly to your cause.

How does Zeffy compare to payment processors for fundraising events?

Zeffy offers complete event management including ticketing, auctions, and raffles at zero cost. PayPal and Square only process payments - you'd need separate tools for events, adding complexity and extra fees to your fundraising.

What makes Zeffy better than PayPal or Square for donor relationships?

Zeffy includes built-in donor management, automated tax receipts, and email marketing tools at no charge. PayPal and Square only track basic transactions - you'd need costly third-party software for donor relationships and communications.

Looking for a better option?

Related content

What makes Zeffy different

Zeffy was built for nonprofits like yours

focus on what matters

Built for small teams with big missions.

Zeffy is the fundraising platform that cuts out the fees, clears up your tech mess, and puts your cause first — so your team, even if you're a small team wearing many hats or a one-person show, can focus on what really matters.

Start your nonprofit
Sign up for free

ZERO-FEE

Keep 100% of every dollar.

No platform fees. No processing fees. No catch. We know it sounds too good to be true, but it's not. Every penny goes straight to your mission, while competitors take 2-3% off every donation.

Start your nonprofit
How is Zeffy free?

ALL-IN-ONE PLatform

Ditch the tech mess.

Stop bouncing between MailChimp, Eventbrite, and all those spreadsheets. Now you can handle donations, ticket sales, memberships, raffles, and all your donor info in one spot.

Start your nonprofit
Sign up for free

plug-and-play

Get going, fast.

Built for teams like yours — whether you're volunteer-led or have limited staff. Set up donation forms, sell tickets, and launch campaigns without needing a tech wizard. It's super easy, and you'll be up and running in minutes.

Start your nonprofit
Sign up for free

mobile-first

Fundraise from every device, anywhere.

From QR codes on flyers to Tap-to-Pay on a phone, Zeffy makes it easy to accept donations on the go. Mobile-optimized and offline-ready, so no donor slips through the cracks.

Start your nonprofit
Sign up for free

No turnover

Never lose a donor to volunteer transition.

Centralize supporter relationships, automate thank-you messages, and preserve institutional knowledge when board members rotate out.

Start your nonprofit
Sign up for free
Sign up to Zeffy for free
100% free forever.

100,000+ nonprofits trust Zeffy — and keep their fees at $0.

For 7+ years, Zeffy has supported nonprofits with free, user-friendly fundraising tools.

As a startup nonprofit with only two members, and no funding (yet) we’d need something with low (or no) fees. Zeffy was a dream come true.

Masey, Loose Ends.

Read the full story
Decorative
“We were incurring a ton of fees for our past fundraising platform and Zeffy has helped us receive so much more of our donations.”
Amy R
Amy R
Rebuilding Together Metro Chicago
Zeffy has been invaluable in helping me track our donors, sales, events, and revenue in one spot. The coolest thing about Zeffy is it really is free!
Debra B
Debra B
Glory to Glory Women's Mentoring Ministry
Everything about Zeffy suits us starting with (of course, NO fees) but also the ease of use and customer experience as well as their client support!!
Carmen M
Carmen M
DIVINA World Foundation
Zeffy is very easy to use and ensures that every dollar quickly gets into our account.. A huge help to our work!
Nathan C
Nathan C
Jiwa International
Zeffy is very simple, allows for a lot of customization and seamlessly integrates into our website. The fact that all of this is free is still wild to me.
Ryan S
Ryan S
Jesters Theatre: Youth Unlimited
We couldn't believe there was a free payment platform for our Girl Scout group. Zeffy took ZERO fees from us, which is huge when you run on very small amounts of money.
Jennifer H
Jennifer H
GSCB Troop 144
We were ready to sell tickets in less than 30 minutes. The reporting capabilities were better than some other paid-for sites.
Mark B
Mark B
Theta Mu Lambda Charitable Foundation
Since using Zeffy, our conversion rate of donations has skyrocketed. It's an easy platform to use. Plus customer support has always been responsive and helpful!
Stevie C
Stevie C
We Are HER