FirstGiving Is Being Phased Out — Here's a Zero-Fee Alternative Built for Small Teams

FirstGiving takes up to 7.5% and is moving to enterprise-only. Zeffy charges $0 and is ready now.

Decorative

Zeffy is trusted by 100,000+ nonprofits

Sign up to Zeffy for free - 100% free forever.
FirstGiving
logo-white-Zeffy
Decorative

Zeffy VS FirstGiving

Zeffy VS FirstGiving: What nonprofits should know before choosing.

Zeffy
FirstGiving
Pricing
Zeffy:

$

0.

Completely free. Always. But how? →

FirstGiving:

Varies.

5% platform cut + 2.5% card fees

Processing fees
Zeffy:

$

0.

$0 in credit card and transaction fees. Zeffy covers these. How? →

FirstGiving:

2.9% + $0.30.

per transaction; 1.9% + 20p for UK cards per some sources; 2.5% credit card fees per some sources

Platform fees
Zeffy:

$

0.

Zeffy never takes a cut. Unlike platforms that skim 3–5%, you keep 100% of every donation.

FirstGiving:

2.9%.

of each donation (or 5% per some sources)

Monthly fees
Zeffy:

$

0/month.

No subscriptions, no paywalls. Every org, big or small, gets full access for free.

FirstGiving:

N/A.

No monthly fees information available

Other fees
Zeffy:

$

0.

We've never charged a single cent to nonprofits and we never will.

FirstGiving:

N/A.

No other fees information available

Pricing transparency
Zeffy:

10/10.

No platform fees, no credit card fees, no hidden fees, no fees period!

FirstGiving:

3/10.

No pricing page found. Fees only discoverable through comparison sites, not FirstGiving directly.

Value for money
Zeffy:

5/5.

450+ reviews on Capterra. All-in-one fundraising, zero fees, unbeatable value.

FirstGiving:

N/A.

Features
Zeffy:

5/5.

No training needed. Built for busy nonprofit teams, not tech pros. Launch a campaign in under 30 minutes.

FirstGiving:

N/A.

Now part of Frontstream Panorama - enterprise platform with complex setup and limited tools for small nonprofits

Donations
Zeffy:
Yes

Donations without the cut. Custom forms, tax receipts, donor tracking — all fee-free.

FirstGiving:
Yes

FirstGiving (now Frontstream Panorama) offers donation forms with recurring giving - requires paid plan for advanced features

Ticketing
Zeffy:
Yes

Sell tickets, check in guests, track sales — and keep 100%. No fees. No fine print.

FirstGiving:
Yes

Event registration and ticketing available - part of enterprise package with complex setup and training required

Peer-to-Peer Fundraising
Zeffy:
Yes

Teams or individuals launch fundraising pages in minutes. Track progress, keep 100%. No fees.

FirstGiving:
Yes

Peer-to-peer campaigns with fundraiser pages and team tools - available on higher-tier plans only

Auctions
Zeffy:
Yes

Run auctions without giving up a percentage. List items, track bids, collect payments — all fee-free.

FirstGiving:
No

No auction tools - FirstGiving focuses on peer-to-peer and event fundraising, not auction management

Raffles
Zeffy:
Yes

Host online raffles and 50/50s. Track sales, set ticket limits, stay compliant — all without paying a cent.

FirstGiving:
No

No dedicated raffle tools - nonprofits need workarounds or third-party integrations to run compliant raffles

Online Store
Zeffy:
Yes

Skip the tool sprawl. Sell merch and manage your store in one place — no fees, no add-ons.

FirstGiving:
No

No built-in store functionality - requires separate e-commerce platform to sell merchandise or products

Memberships
Zeffy:
Yes

Automate memberships with no per-member fees. Dues go straight to your org — perfect for clubs, alumni, and supporters.

FirstGiving:
No

No membership management - designed for campaign-based fundraising, not ongoing member relationships

Donor management/CRM
Zeffy:
Yes

Ditch the expensive CRM. Track donations, send thank-yous, and build donor loyalty — all fee-free.

FirstGiving:
Yes

Donor database with giving history and basic segmentation - limited compared to dedicated CRM platforms

Emails & Newsletter
Zeffy:
Yes

Manage contacts and send newsletters from the same place you fundraise. Unlimited sends, no fees.

FirstGiving:
Yes

Basic automated thank-you emails and receipts - no campaign builder or donor newsletter tools

Payment Processing
Zeffy:
Yes

Accept donations, ticket sales, and payments — all 100% fee-free. No cuts, no hidden fees, ever.

FirstGiving:
Yes

Integrated payment processing through Frontstream with automated receipts and multi-currency support

Payment Methods
Zeffy:
Yes

All-in-one fundraising: donations, events, memberships, email, and donor CRM — 100% free.

FirstGiving:
Yes

Credit cards and ACH only. No digital wallets, and in-person payments require third-party hardware.

Credit Card Payments
Zeffy:
Yes

Accept all major credit cards with zero processing fees. Zeffy covers the cost — you keep 100% of every donation.

FirstGiving:
Yes

All major credit and debit cards accepted through Frontstream's payment processing system

Apple Pay & Google Pay
Zeffy:
Yes

One-tap donations and tickets with Apple Pay & Google Pay. No fees, just smooth mobile checkouts.

FirstGiving:
No

No digital wallet support - donors must enter card details manually for all transactions

ACH / Bank Transfers
Zeffy:
Yes

Accept bank transfers with zero fees. Full donation amounts go straight to your mission.

FirstGiving:
Yes

ACH bank transfers available but requires donors to set up bank account verification through their portal

Tap to Pay App
Zeffy:
Yes

Anyone on your team can take payments from their phone. No card reader, no fees, no friction.

FirstGiving:
No

No native in-person payment tools - requires separate hardware purchase and third-party integration

Support
Zeffy:

5/5.

Real humans, real fast. Free email and phone support — no bots, no paywalls, no runaround.

FirstGiving:

N/A.

Platform being phased out after acquisition. Support now focused on migrating FirstGiving users to Frontstream's enterprise tools, with limited help for small nonprofits.

Help Center
Zeffy:
Yes

Searchable help docs, video tutorials, and step-by-step guides — all free, all the time.

FirstGiving:
Yes

Knowledge base and help articles exist but are being migrated to Frontstream; some FirstGiving-specific guides may be missing or outdated.

Email Support
Zeffy:
Yes

Email us anytime. Most questions answered within hours — not days.

FirstGiving:
Yes

Email support is available, but it's limited since FirstGiving was integrated into Frontstream; responses can be slower and dedicated help is scarce.

Phone Support
Zeffy:
Yes

Need to talk? Call us. Real support from real people who understand nonprofits.

FirstGiving:
Yes

Phone support exists through Frontstream but is geared toward enterprise clients — small nonprofits may not have access.

Onboarding
Zeffy:
Yes

Get set up in under 30 minutes. No training required — but we're here if you need us.

FirstGiving:
No

No dedicated onboarding for small nonprofits; any hands-on migration or onboarding support is focused on Frontstream enterprise customers.

Community
Zeffy:
Yes

Join thousands of nonprofits sharing tips, templates, and best practices.

FirstGiving:
No

No active community forum for FirstGiving users; support is handled through Frontstream's enterprise channels rather than public user groups.

Zeffy is 100% free, always.

Why Zeffy over FirstGiving?

Keep 100% of every donation, no platform fees or surprises

🆓

Keep 100% of every donation, no platform fees or surprises

FirstGiving takes up to 7.5% per donation and is migrating to an enterprise model. Zeffy is 100% free, built for small nonprofits, and ready to use today.

📲

Your donors shouldn't need a manual to give

FirstGiving requires donors to verify bank accounts and enter card details manually. Zeffy accepts Apple Pay, Google Pay, and ACH with no extra steps.

🤝

You shouldn't have to guess what support you'll get

FirstGiving is being phased into Frontstream's enterprise model. Zeffy gives you unlimited email, chat, and phone support built for small teams, not corporations.

Questions nonprofits ask when choosing between Zeffy and FirstGiving

Is Zeffy really 100% free, or are there hidden fees?

Zeffy is completely free for nonprofits. There are no platform fees, processing fees, or monthly charges. Donors have the option to leave a voluntary contribution to keep Zeffy running, but you keep 100% of every donation.

Can I switch from FirstGiving to Zeffy without losing my donor data?

Yes. You can export your donor data from FirstGiving and import it into Zeffy. Our support team helps you migrate your contacts, donation history, and campaigns so you can start fundraising right away.

How does Zeffy make money if there are no fees?

Donors have the option to leave a voluntary contribution when they give. This covers all our costs so nonprofits never pay a cent. You keep 100% of donations, and we stay sustainable.

Does Zeffy work for peer-to-peer campaigns and team fundraising?

Yes. Zeffy includes peer-to-peer fundraising with custom fundraiser pages, team tools, and progress tracking. All features are free, with no enterprise upgrade required.

Donors can give using credit cards, debit cards, ACH bank transfers, Apple Pay, or Google Pay. All payment methods are included at no extra cost to your nonprofit.

Donors can give using credit cards, debit cards, ACH bank transfers, Apple Pay, or Google Pay. All payment methods are included at no extra cost to your nonprofit.

What fees does FirstGiving charge per donation?

FirstGiving charges up to 5% platform fees plus 2.5% credit card processing fees, meaning you could lose up to 7.5% of every donation. Zeffy charges zero fees, so you keep 100% of what donors give.

Is FirstGiving still available for small nonprofits?

FirstGiving has been absorbed into Frontstream Panorama, an enterprise-focused platform with complex setup requirements. If you're a small team or grassroots organization, Zeffy is built specifically for you with quick setup and no learning curve.

How long does it take to set up Zeffy compared to FirstGiving?

You can launch your first Zeffy donation form in under 30 minutes with no training required. FirstGiving's enterprise model typically involves a more complex onboarding process.

Does Zeffy offer event ticketing and auctions like FirstGiving?

Yes. Zeffy includes ticketing, auctions, raffles, peer-to-peer campaigns, an online store, memberships, and a built-in CRM — all completely free. FirstGiving requires paid plans or enterprise packages for advanced features.

Can donors use Apple Pay or Google Pay with Zeffy?

Yes. Zeffy accepts credit cards, debit cards, ACH bank transfers, Apple Pay, and Google Pay at no extra cost. FirstGiving only supports credit cards and ACH.

Still undecided?

Keep comparing — and see why nonprofits choose Zeffy

No items found.

100,000+ nonprofits trust Zeffy — and keep their fees at $0.

For 7+ years, Zeffy has supported nonprofits with free, user-friendly fundraising tools.

As a startup nonprofit with only two members, and no funding (yet) we’d need something with low (or no) fees. Zeffy was a dream come true.

Masey, Loose Ends.

Read the full story
Decorative
“We were incurring a ton of fees for our past fundraising platform and Zeffy has helped us receive so much more of our donations.”
Amy R
Amy R
Rebuilding Together Metro Chicago
Zeffy has been invaluable in helping me track our donors, sales, events, and revenue in one spot. The coolest thing about Zeffy is it really is free!
Debra B
Debra B
Glory to Glory Women's Mentoring Ministry
Everything about Zeffy suits us starting with (of course, NO fees) but also the ease of use and customer experience as well as their client support!!
Carmen M
Carmen M
DIVINA World Foundation
Zeffy is very easy to use and ensures that every dollar quickly gets into our account.. A huge help to our work!
Nathan C
Nathan C
Jiwa International
Zeffy is very simple, allows for a lot of customization and seamlessly integrates into our website. The fact that all of this is free is still wild to me.
Ryan S
Ryan S
Jesters Theatre: Youth Unlimited
We couldn't believe there was a free payment platform for our Girl Scout group. Zeffy took ZERO fees from us, which is huge when you run on very small amounts of money.
Jennifer H
Jennifer H
GSCB Troop 144
We were ready to sell tickets in less than 30 minutes. The reporting capabilities were better than some other paid-for sites.
Mark B
Mark B
Theta Mu Lambda Charitable Foundation
Since using Zeffy, our conversion rate of donations has skyrocketed. It's an easy platform to use. Plus customer support has always been responsive and helpful!
Stevie C
Stevie C
We Are HER