The 8 Best PayPal Alternatives for UK Charities (2026)

‍

In this article:

• Why UK charities are moving beyond PayPal in 2026

• Quick comparison: 8 PayPal alternatives at a glance

• The 8 best PayPal alternatives for UK charities

• How to choose the right PayPal alternative

• When to switch from PayPal (and when to stay)

• Frequently asked questions

‍

Why UK charities are moving beyond PayPal in 2026

Most PayPal-alternative articles miss the number that actually matters: how much does PayPal cost a typical UK charity per year, and what does that money fail to fund? On 500 donations at a £20 average, a realistic year for a small charity, PayPal's registered UK charity rate of 1.9% + 20p removes around £290 from £10,000 raised. At £3.50 a meal, that is 82 meals a food bank did not get to serve. Every pound PayPal takes is a pound that does not reach your cause.

But fees are only part of the story. The bigger issue for UK charities is Gift Aid. In the UK, your charity reclaims 25p from HMRC for every £1 a UK taxpayer donates, turning a £100 gift into £125 at no extra cost to the donor. PayPal collects a Gift Aid declaration but does not integrate with HMRC Charities Online. Your treasurer still has to export donor records, reconcile declarations, and file the claim manually. A platform that handles Gift Aid declarations, records, and the claim workflow saves hours per month, not just fees. (HMRC Gift Aid guidance)

There is a second issue many UK charities discover too late. When a donor gives through PayPal Giving Fund, the legal gift goes to PayPal Giving Fund, a separately registered UK charity, not to your organisation directly. That means any Gift Aid on those donations is claimed by PayPal Giving Fund, not by you. You also lose the direct donor relationship and the data that goes with it. If Gift Aid income and donor stewardship matter to your charity (they should), this is a serious structural problem with PayPal as a primary giving channel.

PayPal's only genuine advantage for UK charities is donor name recognition. Some supporters only trust the PayPal logo, and that is a real conversion factor. The honest 2026 verdict: keep a small PayPal donate button as a backup for the donors who insist on it, and run your primary giving through a platform built for UK charities.

‍

Quick comparison: 8 PayPal alternatives at a glance

All effective-fee figures below assume a £20 donation and the platform's published UK charity rate. Fees verified against live UK compare pages on zeffy.com/compare (2026-06-19). Verify current rates on each provider's pricing page before switching.

‍

‍

The 8 best PayPal alternatives for UK charities

1. Zeffy: the only zero-fee PayPal alternative ✅

Ideal for: charities that want every pound to reach the cause with no monthly subscription.

No platform fee, no transaction fee, no credit card fee. Ever. A £20 gift on Zeffy arrives as £20 in your account. Zeffy stays in business because some donors choose to add an optional contribution at checkout alongside their donation. That contribution is genuinely optional, and Zeffy's free model does not depend on any single donor adding one.

Zeffy is used by 100,000+ charities and has helped raise over £2 billion. It runs on Stripe infrastructure but covers all processing costs for the charity. The platform covers donation forms, recurring giving, peer-to-peer pages, ticketed events, auctions, raffles, an in-app donor CRM, automated Gift Aid declarations at checkout, a built-in newsletter tool, and Apple Pay and Google Pay at checkout. For in-person collection at fetes, quiz nights, or church halls, Tap to Pay on a phone turns any smartphone into a card reader with no hardware and no monthly SumUp or Zettle fee.

What supporters and treasurers like:

• £0 fees on every transaction. The charity keeps 100% of each gift.

• One login covers donations, events, peer-to-peer, auctions, donor records, and Gift Aid declarations.

• Setup takes under an hour. No demo call, no contract, no minimum income requirement.

• Apple Pay and Google Pay one-tap checkout with no donor account required.

• Free Tap to Pay app for in-person giving without buying any hardware.

What users mention as drawbacks:

• Not built for developer-led, fully custom checkout flows the way Stripe is.

• Donors see the optional contribution prompt at checkout, which a small number prefer to skip.

The Zeffy interface is easy to use and delivers attractive materials for social media and email. We used it for event registration, peer-to-peer campaigns, and donations. If you're sceptical about their business model, we can tell you there are no catches or loopholes on the financial side. They took zero percent of our fundraising income. Michael, via Capterra

A closer look at the fee comparison with PayPal (500 donations at £20 average, £10,000 raised):

‍

‍

‍

For a small charity: Zeffy is the honest number one because it is the only entry on this list that solves all four common PayPal frustrations (fees eating small gifts, no Gift Aid automation, no donor records, compliance holds) at £0. If you raise under £50k a year, this is the answer.

Coming soon: Zeffy is adding PayPal as a checkout option on its forms, so you will soon be able to let donors pay with PayPal while your charity keeps 100% of every gift, with no platform fee. You get PayPal's familiarity at checkout without PayPal's 1.9% + 20p cut.

‍

2. Donorbox: adds a platform fee on top of Stripe processing ✅

Ideal for: charities that need form customisation Zeffy does not offer and can absorb the platform fee.

Donorbox is the closest functional alternative to a charity-native PayPal replacement. The Standard plan is £0/month with a 2.95% platform fee. The Pro plan is £150/month and drops the platform fee to 1.75%. Processing runs through Stripe at 1.5% + 20p for UK cards. On a £20 gift through the Standard plan with Stripe, the effective fee is approximately £0.80, or around 4%.

Donorbox provides donation records, recurring donations, Apple Pay and Google Pay, and embeddable forms. Events and memberships carry a higher fee rate. Text-to-Give and Kiosk are paid add-ons. There are no auctions.

What users like:

• Quick-to-launch donation forms with strong recurring giving.

• Embeds cleanly on existing websites.

• Built-in donor management with basic CRM features.

• Works with Stripe for processing.

What users mention as drawbacks:

• Platform fee stacks on top of processing, so a £20 gift loses approximately 4%.

• The £150/month Pro tier is a significant cost for a small charity raising under £50k.

• Gift Aid handling is not automated to HMRC standard.

We've seen an increase in recurring donations thanks to the seamless checkout process, and the integrations with our website and communication tools save us valuable time. While there are a few premium features behind a paywall, the value we get overall has far exceeded expectations. Sara, via Capterra

For a small charity: Workable if you need a specific form feature Zeffy does not have. Otherwise the platform fee is real money you do not need to spend.

‍

3. CAF Donate: the trust-first UK charity-native option ✅

Ideal for: charities whose trustees want a recognised UK institution behind the donate button.

CAF Donate is built by the Charities Aid Foundation, itself a registered UK charity and one of the oldest charity infrastructure bodies in the country. More than 8,000 small-to-medium UK charities use it. There is no monthly subscription; fees vary by payment type and are lower than most commercial alternatives. Direct Debit is supported alongside card giving.

CAF Donate is the option for a charity whose trustees are cautious about adopting a new platform and want a name they already recognise. It is not the most feature-rich interface on this list, but it is trusted, well-supported, and fee-efficient. The Charity Commission's register confirms CAF's regulated UK charity status, which carries weight with trustees.

What users like:

• Trustees and senior staff recognise the CAF name immediately.

• No monthly subscription; fees apply per donation.

• Direct Debit support alongside card giving.

• Gift Aid claim support built into the CAF infrastructure.

What users mention as drawbacks:

• Reporting is more basic compared to commercial fundraising platforms.

• Less customisation than Zeffy or Donorbox.

• Does not cover event ticketing, auctions, or peer-to-peer fundraising natively.

For a small charity: A solid choice if donor trust and institutional credibility are the primary concern. For a charity that also needs ticketing, raffles, or peer-to-peer, CAF Donate needs to be paired with other tools. Zeffy covers all of those in one free platform.

‍

4. Wonderful.org: genuinely 0% via Pay by Bank ✅

Ideal for: charities that can send donors direct and do not need a discovery marketplace.

Wonderful.org uses Open Banking, Pay by Bank, account-to-account transfers, to eliminate platform fees entirely on that rail. There is no platform fee, no Gift Aid processing charge, and no card processing fee on Pay by Bank transactions. Card transactions carry standard processing costs.

Wonderful.org is one of the lowest-cost giving options available to UK charities. The 100%-to-charity promise is genuine on the Open Banking rail, and the platform's ethical positioning resonates with cost-conscious donors.

What users like:

• 0% fees on Pay by Bank donations: every pound reaches the charity.

• No platform fee and no Gift Aid processing charge.

• Strong ethical positioning for cost-conscious UK donors.

What users mention as drawbacks:

• Narrower reach than JustGiving: no cold-donor discovery marketplace.

• The Pay by Bank journey converts well with younger, digitally confident donors and poorly with older donors unfamiliar with bank app authentication.

• Smaller UK profile means some donors may not recognise the platform.

For a small charity: If you can send your own donors direct and do not rely on platform discovery, this is one of the most cost-effective options in the UK. If you need to attract new donors through the platform itself, JustGiving or a wider-reach option serves better.

‍

5. Stripe: payment rails, not a fundraising platform ❌

Ideal for: charities with a developer on the team.

Stripe is the payment infrastructure most platforms on this list, including Zeffy, run on. Used directly, it gives you 1.5% + 20p per transaction for standard UK cards, higher for European Economic Area and international cards. There is no publicly listed UK charity discount. Contact Stripe UK sales for charity pricing, which is not published.

The honest issue for charities is that Stripe is infrastructure. Out of the box, it provides none of the essentials: no automated Gift Aid declarations, no donor CRM, no donation forms, and no recurring giving dashboard. Everything has to be built or connected via a third-party platform.

What users like:

• Fast payouts and clean reporting.

• International card support.

• Strong developer documentation.

What users mention as drawbacks:

• No Gift Aid handling, no donor records, no donation forms out of the box.

• Requires a developer or a third-party platform to be usable for fundraising.

• The standard rate still adds up across many small gifts.

For a small charity: Skip unless you have a developer on the team. Stripe is rails, not a fundraising platform.

‍

6. Square / SumUp / Zettle: for in-person card payments at events ⚠️

Ideal for: charities that need dedicated card hardware at fetes, quiz nights, or fundraising dinners.

Square, SumUp, and Zettle are the most common tap-to-pay card readers at UK charity events, fetes, and church halls. In the UK, SumUp and Zettle are the readers most frequently seen at community fundraisers; Square is available but less dominant here than in other markets.

In-person rates vary by provider and hardware model. None of these tools provides automated Gift Aid handling, donor records, or recurring giving. For online giving, they are not fundraising platforms.

UK charity VoC research makes the case clearly: "people are not carrying around cash like they used to... they have no credit card transaction mechanisms." Dedicated card hardware solves that problem at the door. It does not solve online giving, Gift Aid, or donor management.

If you need in-person collection without hardware costs, Zeffy's Tap to Pay app does the same job on any smartphone with £0 fees and no monthly subscription.

What users like:

• Works straight away for door sales and event collection.

• Familiar to UK event volunteers.

• Real-time in-person payments without a separate POS system.

What users mention as drawbacks:

• No charity discount; fees apply on every transaction.

• No Gift Aid handling, no donor records, no recurring giving.

• Advanced features sit behind paid subscriptions or hardware costs.

For a small charity: Useful at the door on the night. Do not make it your online giving platform.

‍

7. GoCardless: the UK standard for regular giving ⚠️

Ideal for: charities setting up Direct Debit for regular givers, used alongside a full fundraising platform.

GoCardless is the UK leader in Direct Debit for charities. Direct Debit accounts for approximately 31% of all UK charity donations, making it the single largest payment method for regular giving in this country. If your charity wants to offer monthly standing-order-style donations, GoCardless is the most accessible route without going through a full Bacs bureau.

Fees are 1% + 20p per Direct Debit transaction, capped at £2 per payment. A 25% charity discount is available on application. GoCardless also offers Instant Bank Pay for one-off Open Banking payments.

GoCardless is payment infrastructure. It does not provide donation forms, automated Gift Aid declarations, a donor CRM, or event ticketing. Nearly every major UK fundraising platform integrates GoCardless under the hood. You are more likely to use GoCardless through a platform than directly.

What users like:

• Direct Debit is the gold standard for UK regular giving.

• The most accessible route to Direct Debit without a full Bacs bureau agreement.

• Widely integrated with UK fundraising platforms and CRMs.

What users mention as drawbacks:

• It is a payment rail, not a fundraising platform: no forms, no Gift Aid handling, no CRM.

• Not a standalone alternative to PayPal for one-off donations.

• The charity discount is available but requires an application; it is not automatic.

For a small charity: Essential infrastructure for regular giving, but not a standalone PayPal replacement. Use it through a full platform like Zeffy, not instead of one.

‍

8. PayPal (as a backup only): name recognition, poor primary platform ❌

Ideal for: charities with a meaningful share of donors who only trust the PayPal logo.

The registered UK charity rate is 1.9% + 20p per donation. If your charity has not completed PayPal's charity verification, the standard business rate applies instead. On a £20 verified-charity gift, the fee is approximately £0.58. Across 500 donations at £20 average, that is around £290 removed from £10,000 raised.

Beyond the fees, PayPal provides no automated Gift Aid declarations connected to HMRC Charities Online, no donor management, and no recurring giving dashboard. The 20p flat fee is the sharpest pain on small gifts, including £5 and £10 donations.

There is also the PayPal Giving Fund issue. When a UK donor gives through PayPal Giving Fund, the donation goes legally to PayPal Giving Fund, a separately registered UK charity, not to your organisation. Gift Aid on those donations is claimed by PayPal Giving Fund, not by you. You also lose the direct donor relationship and the accompanying data. If Gift Aid and donor stewardship matter, this is a structural problem that makes PayPal a poor primary channel.

What users like:

• Donor name recognition. Some supporters only trust the PayPal logo.

• Fast setup if a donate button is your only immediate requirement.

• The registered charity rate is lower than the standard business rate once charity verification is complete.

What users mention as drawbacks:

• No automated Gift Aid handling or HMRC-connected donor records.

• 20p flat fee on every gift, including small £5 and £10 donations.

• PayPal Giving Fund breaks the direct donor relationship and the Gift Aid claim.

• Standard business rate applies until charity verification is complete.

The honest framing: keep a small PayPal donate button on your site as a backup for the donors who only trust the PayPal logo. Stop sending it as your main donation link.

For a small charity: Backup only. The fees, the absence of Gift Aid automation, and the PayPal Giving Fund issue make it a poor primary channel.

‍

How to choose the right PayPal alternative

Choose by organisation size and the work you actually do, not by the longest feature list.

‍

Small: under £50k raised per year

• Primary: Zeffy. Zero fees, built-in donor CRM, Gift Aid declarations, recurring giving, peer-to-peer, auctions, all in one free login.

• Alternative: CAF Donate if your trustees want a recognised UK institution behind the donate button.

• Supplementary: PayPal donate button as a small backup for donors who insist on it.

For a small charity, the only real question is whether you want £0 in fees with no application (Zeffy) or a trusted UK charity institution with somewhat higher fees (CAF Donate).

‍

Mid: £50k to £500k raised per year

• Primary: Zeffy. The free model scales without adding a monthly cost.

• Alternative: Wonderful.org if you can drive donors direct and the Open Banking journey fits your donor profile.

• If you have a developer: Stripe for fully custom checkout flows.

For a mid-size charity, the bottleneck at this stage is usually staff time, not features. Pick the platform that removes the most manual work.

‍

Large: £500k+ raised per year

• Primary: Zeffy still works at this size, with built-in donor management that removes the need for a separate CRM bill.

• If donor retention is the bottleneck: Consider Beacon (the UK's number-one fundraising CRM for six years running, from £33.50/month) or Donorfy (from around £50/month above 500 constituents). Both are purpose-built UK fundraising CRMs.

• If you have ecommerce-style needs: Stripe with a custom build.

‍

In-person heavy: fetes, quiz nights, church halls

• Primary: Zeffy Tap to Pay (no hardware, £0 fees, any smartphone).

• Alternative: SumUp or Zettle if you specifically want a dedicated card reader. GoodBox if you are a museum, church, or visitor attraction that wants a fixed contactless donation device. (See the Zeffy vs GoodBox comparison for a full fee breakdown.)

Whichever platform you choose, check that it operates in line with the Fundraising Regulator's Code of Fundraising Practice (current version effective 1 November 2025, including Section 9 on online platforms) and handles UK GDPR and PECR for your donor data.

‍

When to switch from PayPal (and when to stay)

Switch when any of these are true:

• You want Gift Aid claims automated, not exported and re-keyed into HMRC Charities Online each quarter.

• Your donors are giving through PayPal Giving Fund and you have realised those gifts are Gift-Aided by PayPal Giving Fund, not by your charity, so donor stewardship breaks.

• Fees are eating £10 and £20 gifts (the 20p flat fee is the worst offender on small donations).

• Donors are asking whether your link is genuine because the PayPal page does not look like your charity.

• Older supporters are abandoning checkout because PayPal asks them to create an account.

• You are tracking donors in a spreadsheet because PayPal exports do not give you what you need.

• You are running events or regular giving programmes and the PayPal donate button cannot keep up.

Stay (as a backup) when:

• A meaningful share of your donor base only trusts the PayPal logo. Keep a small donate button as a backup. Move your primary donation link to a platform built for UK charities.

Switching off PayPal is worth it for almost every small UK charity raising more than around £5,000 a year. The fees, the manual Gift Aid process, and the time spent on administration cost more than the migration. The single best move you can make this quarter is to stop sending the PayPal donate link as your main donation channel.

‍

‍

Frequently asked questions

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍